Using an Installment Sale to Spread the Gain on a Hawthorne Rental

Published August 10, 2026

Selling your Hawthorne rental on an installment note under section 453 lets you spread the capital gain across the years you collect payments, but depreciation recapture doesn't get that treatment. It's taxed in full in the year of sale no matter how little cash you've actually received.

The short answer

An installment sale under section 453 lets you spread the capital gain on your Hawthorne rental across the years you actually collect payments from the buyer, rather than paying tax on the whole gain the year you sell. Depreciation recapture income does not get this deferral. Under 26 U.S.C. section 453(i)(1)(A), recapture income is recognized in full in the year of the sale regardless of how much cash you've collected. The sale is reported on Form 6252.

Last verified: August 10, 2026

Why sellers reach for an installment sale

Selling a fully appreciated Hawthorne rental outright, particularly one held for years near the Metro Green Line corridor or the older single family and small multifamily stock closer to Hawthorne Boulevard, can produce a gain large enough to push the seller into a higher tax bracket for the entire amount in a single year. An installment sale, where the buyer pays you over time under a note instead of all cash at closing, spreads the capital gain recognition across the years payments actually arrive. Each payment received is split between return of basis, capital gain, and interest income on the note, based on a gross profit percentage calculated up front.

This can meaningfully lower the average tax rate on the gain compared to a single year lump sum, since less of it stacks on top of your ordinary income in any one year.

The part sellers miss: recapture doesn't spread

Section 453(i) carves out a specific exception, and it's the one that trips up landlords who assume installment treatment defers everything proportionally. The statute states that notwithstanding the general installment method rule in subsection (a), any recapture income is recognized in the year of the disposition.

That means: if your rental sale includes depreciation recapture, whether that's section 1250 recapture, unrecaptured section 1250 gain, or section 1245 recapture on any personal property sold with the building, that recapture amount is taxed in full on your return for the year you sell, not spread across the note's payment schedule. According to Publication 537, you must report any depreciation recapture income in the year of sale whether or not an installment payment was received that year.

Practically, this can mean a seller owes tax on recapture income before they've collected the cash to pay for it, if the down payment is small and most of the sale price is deferred into future note payments. Only the gain in excess of the recapture amount is eligible to be spread using the installment method.

Working through the mechanics

| Component of your gain | Installment sale treatment |

|---|---|

| Depreciation recapture (section 1250 recapture, unrecaptured section 1250 gain, section 1245 recapture on personal property) | Fully taxed in the year of sale, per section 453(i)(1)(A), regardless of payments actually received |

| Remaining capital gain above the recapture amount | Spread over the years you receive payments, using a gross profit percentage applied to each payment |

| Interest on the note | Ordinary interest income, reported separately as you receive it, not part of the capital gain calculation |

A Hawthorne landlord selling a rental with $150,000 of accumulated depreciation and a $400,000 total gain, financed with a modest down payment and the balance paid over five years, would owe tax on the full $150,000 of recapture in the year of sale. Only the remaining $250,000 of gain is eligible to be spread across the five year payment term as those payments come in.

Reporting the sale

According to Publication 537, Form 6252 is generally the form used to report installment sale income from casual sales of real or personal property during the tax year. Depending on the type of property sold, the results also flow to Schedule D for the capital gain portion, Form 4797 for any section 1250 or 1245 recapture and any business property component, or both. The recapture income itself is reported in the year of sale on the appropriate recapture line, separate from the deferred capital gain reported via the installment method in later years.

A liftable summary

An installment sale defers capital gain, not recapture. Before structuring the note, calculate your depreciation recapture amount first, confirm you can cover the tax on that amount from the down payment or other funds in the year of sale, and only then structure how much of the remaining gain to spread and over what term.

FAQ

Does section 453 let me defer depreciation recapture if I structure a small enough down payment?

No. Under 26 U.S.C. section 453(i)(1)(A), recapture income is recognized in the year of disposition regardless of the payment structure or how little cash actually changed hands that year.

What form reports an installment sale on a Hawthorne rental?

Form 6252, according to Publication 537, with the results also flowing to Schedule D and/or Form 4797 depending on the property type and whether recapture is involved.

Can I use an installment sale and a 1031 exchange together?

That's a distinct structuring question involving different code sections and isn't something I verified in this research pass. Confirm with a CPA before combining the two.

Does the buyer's interest payments on the note count as part of my capital gain?

No. Interest on the installment note is separate ordinary interest income to you, reported as received, and is not part of the capital gain calculation under section 453.

What if the buyer defaults on the note partway through?

Repossession and default on an installment sale note involve their own separate rules under Publication 537 that weren't covered in this research pass. This is a scenario to discuss with a CPA before you finalize a note structure.

Is there a minimum sale price or property type requirement to use the installment method?

This article did not verify eligibility thresholds or property type exclusions for installment sale treatment. Confirm eligibility for your specific sale with a CPA.

This is general information, not tax advice. Confirm the recapture calculation, the gross profit percentage, and the note structure for your specific sale with a CPA before you close.

Topics: taxes, installment sale, section 453, depreciation recapture, hawthorne

Get a free management quote

Back to the Schofield Properties blog

Schofield Properties is a family run property management company at 323 Richmond St, El Segundo, CA 90245. We have managed the South Bay since 1972 and personally oversee about 186 doors today. Book a call to talk about your property.